Results of the Steady-State Calculation

Evaluate the results of the steady-state calculation: false color in the network, result tables, pressure profile to the index point and pump design

VICUS Districts Page 3 of 3 in this chapter

Overview

After the calculation, VICUS Districts presents the results per operating point: as false color in the 3D network, in result tables for pipes, energy plants and consumers, as a check of the whole network against the permissible pressures, as a path profile along a supply path (pressure profile to the index point) and in the pump sizing. The results are part of the project file and remain available after reopening the project.

Access

Steady-State Calculation button in the left-hand toolbar. At the top, the view contains the network selection and the operating-point list, and below it the four areas Results, Pressure check, Path profile and Pump sizing.

Selecting an Operating Point

The Operating Point table lists all calculated operating points with their status. Selecting a row switches all displays (colors, tables, pressure check, profile, pump sizing) to that operating point.

StatusMeaning
ValidCalculation converged, no anomalies
Warninge.g. non-converged nodes, very low temperatures, deviation from the target temperature / pressure difference at the index point or a violated pressure limit (see Pressure check); a detail button opens a dialog with recommended solutions and – for pressure violations – the complete result of the pressure check with the location of each limit

After changes to the network or to referenced database elements, the note “Network has changed - results may be outdated” appears — then repeat the calculation.

Results Area

The Results area contains four tabs: Pipe Network, Energy Plants, Consumers and Summary. The selected result quantity colors the network in the 3D scene (false color with color legend) and highlights the corresponding table column.

ElementFunction
Result quantityQuantity for network coloring and column highlighting
Adjust tableShow and hide table columns
Show flow directionArrowheads on the pipes indicate the calculated mass-flux direction (default: enabled)
Consider geometric heightincludes the geodetic pressure component from the node heights in the pressure quantities (default: enabled)
Edit legend …Adjust the value range (minimum/maximum) of the color scale
CopyCopy the table to the clipboard

Each table row also contains a Select in scene button that selects the respective object in the 3D view.

Consider geometric height is enabled by default and affects the display only: both variants are stored in the results, so switching does not require a recalculation. Switch the option off and the displayed pressures lack exactly the component that governs whether the operating pressure limits are met — for judging the highest and lowest pressure, leave it on. If all nodes still sit at z = 0, for instance because no elevation query has been run yet, the option has no effect.

Pipe Network

Use the Supply / Return options to select the displayed network side. Available result quantities:

Pressure [bar], Pressure loss per meter [Pa/m], Temperature [°C], Power [kW], Utilization [%], Relative reserve [%], Reserve capacity [kW], Maximum capacity [kW], Volume flow [m³/h], Mass flux [kg/s], Velocity [m/s], Pressure difference [mbar], Pressure exceedance [bar], Heat loss [W], Heat loss per meter [W/m].

Utilization, reserve and capacity refer to the maximum pipe pressure loss configured in the calculation dialog.

Pressure exceedance [bar] reports, per pipe, the amount by which the operating pressure exceeds the nominal pressure rating PN of the assigned pipe type; as long as the limit holds, the value is 0. The value is always ≥ 0 — a shortfall is not reported here. Gauge is checked against gauge, so the comparison is exact; a pipe with no nominal pressure rating assigned is not checked.

The quantity looks at the upper limit only, and at pipes only — valves, fittings and plant components with a rating of their own are left out. The evaporation check against the minimum operating pressure is not part of it; it sits on the Pressure check page and in the network report. The limits themselves are described in Meeting operating pressure limits in heat networks.

Good to know

Utilization [%] and Relative reserve [%] are your quickest view of the sizing quality: routes near 100 % utilization are bottlenecks, routes with high reserve are oversized. Since both quantities refer to the configured maximum pipe pressure loss, you always assess the same reference value as in the pipe sizing. Color the network by them via the result quantity to spot reserves and bottlenecks at a glance.

Energy Plants and Consumers

Tree view per network node with the elements of the assigned plant. Result quantities include: pressure difference [bar], temperature difference [K], supplied heat [kW] (energy plants) or extracted heat [kW] (consumers), inlet and outlet temperature [°C], volume flow [m³/h], inlet and outlet pressure [bar]; depending on the plant type additionally heating power [kW], COP [-], pump efficiency [%] and connection-load utilization [%].

Summary

Key figures of the operating point as a table (name, value, unit):

  • Index point: governing consumer with total pressure difference, pressure difference of the pump(s) and temperature difference. With a central pump, the index point is the consumer with the smallest pressure difference; with decentralized pumps, the consumer with the highest.
  • Energy plants: supplied or dissipated heat per plant, where applicable COP and pump pressure difference, as well as sum values over all plants.
  • Height differences: highest point of the network and the position of the energy plants relative to it. This row is the way into the pressure assessment: the minimum pressure becomes governing at the highest point of the network, the maximum pressure at the lowest — roughly 10 m of height difference correspond to 1 bar. Which limits have to be met is described in Meeting operating pressure limits in heat networks.
  • Pipe network: heat-loss power (total and per length) or, in cold networks, the heat gains, the share of the fittings in the total pipe pressure loss, and the hydraulic extremes with the respective pipe: Highest flow velocity, Highest pressure gradient, Highest pipe utilization, Highest operating pressure and Lowest operating pressure.
Result display of the steady-state calculation with false color and result table
False-color display and result table of an operating point

Pressure check

The Pressure check area checks the whole network at the selected operating point against the permissible pressures. What is checked is always the operating pressure, that is the gauge pressure including the geodetic component – regardless of the display option Consider geometric height, because the limits apply to the pressure that actually stands in the pipes. All four ends of every route are read (supply and return, inlet and outlet each); plants sit between two pipe ends and are therefore included.

LimitCriterion
Upper limitEvery pipe keeps its own nominal pressure rating PN from the pipe database. Gauge is checked against gauge, so the comparison is exact. A pipe without a nominal pressure rating is not limited upwards.
Lower limitNo pipe falls below the min. operating pressure: vapour pressure at the hottest point of the whole network (return included) plus the Minimum pressure margin from the general settings, less the ambient pressure at the project altitude.

The page consists of three parts:

  • Status line above the table: All pipes keep their pressure rating and the minimum operating pressure of the network. – or the violated limits in the same wording as in the operating-point list, e.g. Highest operating pressure: … (limit …). If no pipe of the network carries a nominal pressure rating, the line states that only the minimum operating pressure was verified; without results it reads No pressures to check.
  • Table with one row per route and the columns Pipe, Max. allowed pressure [bar] (the PN of the pipe), Min. allowed pressure [bar] (the min. operating pressure of the network), Supply pressure [bar], Return pressure [bar] and Status. The pressure columns show the higher value of the two pipe ends; the tooltip gives the inlet and outlet pressure. The status reads Valid or names the violation, e.g. Supply: exceeded by 0.55 bar or Return: undercut by …; routes without a pressure result show No results. The rows are shaded green or red, the columns can be sorted, and Select in scene selects the route in the 3D view.
  • Note below the table: how the limits are formed – PN range of the installed pipes, vapour pressure and hottest temperature, safety margin, ambient pressure and project altitude.

While the page is open, the 3D scene colors the network by the same verdict: routes that keep both limits green, routes with a violation red; nodes and energy plants take on the verdict of their pipes. A pipe is only as good as its worst end – supply and return both count.

Special case: if the pipe carrying the highest pressure of the network has no nominal pressure rating of its own, the highest pressure is checked against the lowest nominal pressure rating of the network; the note says so explicitly. If a pipe is above its own rating without carrying the network maximum – for instance a PN 10 branch in a section with higher pressure –, the check lists it in an additional row Highest pressure relative to its own pipe rating.

If an operating point violates one of the limits, it gets the Warning status in the operating-point list, and the calculation dialog does not report the run as successful. The usual remedy is a higher Setpoint of pressure maintenance (pressure too low), or a higher nominal pressure rating or a lower pressure level (pressure too high).

The network report documents the same check in its Pressure check chapter as a table and network plan in the same colors. Both evaluate the same calculation and therefore always reach the same verdict. Which parameters enter is described in Pressure Calculation in the Network; the technical reasoning behind the margins is covered in Meeting operating pressure limits in heat networks.

Path Profile (Pressure Profile)

The Path profile area shows the course of a result quantity along the supply path from an energy plant to a consumer — from the outlet of the source plant via the supply and the consumer plant back through the return. A typical application is the pressure profile to the index point as a basis for the pump design.

  • Select Energy plant and Consumer from a list, by clicking in the 3D scene (pick mode), or zoom to the selected object.
  • Quantity: Temperature [°C], Pressure [bar] or Height [m] (geodetic height profile of the path).
  • Consider geometric height adds the component ρ g Δz\rho \, g \, \Delta z to the displayed pressure course; when disabled, only friction losses are shown.

The path profile does not check the pressure limits; the Pressure check page does that for the whole network.

The Chart tab plots the curves for source plant, supply, consumer plant and return over the route length. The Table tab lists each segment of the path individually — pipes as well as fittings — with the columns node id, plant/pipe, component, temperature [°C], pressure loss dp [mbar], p_in and p_out [bar], mass flux [kg/s], volume flow [m³/h], length l [m], dp/l [Pa/m], velocity v [m/s], zeta value [-] and height [m]. Use Copy to transfer the listing to the clipboard, e.g. for further processing in a spreadsheet.

The profile quantity Height [m] and the table column Height [m] are the tools for checking the node heights numerically: the chart shows the height course of the path, the table the value per segment – this is how you find nodes that were inadvertently left at 0. The values are absolute heights above sea level (height of the project origin plus node height); for the pressure assessment only the difference counts.

Pressure profile along the supply path to the index point
Pressure profile along the path from the energy plant to the index point

Pump Design

The Pump sizing area lists the pumps of the selected operating point with their operating point (volume flow, pressure difference). For the selected pump, VICUS Districts suggests suitable pumps from the database:

ElementFunction
Assignassign the selected database pump to the plant
Edit plant …opens the editor of the associated plant
Custom characteristic curve …create your own pump characteristic curve
Remove characteristic curvereset the pump characteristic curve to default values
Number of parallel pumpsparallel pumps split the volume flow evenly at equal head; the total characteristic curve is stretched horizontally by the factor N

The chart shows the pressure difference [bar] over the volume flow [m³/h] with the pump characteristic curve, plant characteristic curve and operating point. After assigning a pump, the note “Pump has been reassigned - recalculation recommended” appears — run the steady-state calculation again so that the operating point matches the new characteristic curve. Plants with a simplified model cannot receive a pump characteristic curve; switch to a detailed model in the plant editor for that.

Pump design with database suggestions and pump characteristic curves
Pump design: database suggestions and characteristic-curve chart

Saving and Export

  • The results are saved in the project file (including undo/redo) and restored on reopening. A checksum detects intervening changes to the network or databases and marks the results as outdated.
  • For plans, export the result display as DXF; the network itself can additionally be exported as GIS data. All result tables can be copied to the clipboard.
  • The network report collects the key figures, pressure profiles, pipe utilization and pump design of the selected operating points into one continuous document (PDF, Word, HTML or AsciiDoc). The check against the nominal pressure rating and the minimum operating pressure is carried out there.

Stay up to date

New features, tutorials and updates delivered to your inbox.