Transfer station

Detailed transfer-station model: counter-flow heat exchanger with limited capacity, secondary side from heating curve, storage behavior, heat deficit.

VICUS Districts Page 9 of 14 in this chapter

Overview

The transfer station (district sub station) is the detailed consumer model: a counter-flow heat exchanger with limited transfer capacity and a realistic representation of the secondary side (building heating). Unlike the simple heat exchanger, it can only deliver the required heat flux when the temperature conditions allow it – it is thus the correct model for undersupply scenarios, lowered network temperatures and networks with building-specific differing spreads.

How it works

Transfer capacity (UA value)

The transfer capacity of the station is determined from the design values:

UA=Q˙nomΔTlog,nomUA = \frac{\dot Q_{nom}}{\Delta T_{log,nom}}

The logarithmic temperature difference at the design point ΔTlog,nom\Delta T_{log,nom} is the central quality parameter of the station: a smaller value means a larger, more efficient heat exchanger – the station manages with a smaller temperature gap between network and building and achieves lower network return temperatures. Typical values of modern stations are 5–10 K.

If the design temperatures of both sides are known, ΔTlog,nom\Delta T_{log,nom} for the counter-flow heat exchanger can be computed directly. At the warm end the network supply faces the building supply, at the cold end the network return faces the building return:

ΔTlog,nom=ΔTA−ΔTBln⁡ ⁣(ΔTA/ΔTB)withΔTA=Tnet,SF−Tbld,SF ,ΔTB=Tnet,RF−Tbld,RF\Delta T_{log,nom} = \frac{\Delta T_A - \Delta T_B}{\ln\!\left(\Delta T_A / \Delta T_B\right)} \qquad \text{with} \qquad \Delta T_A = T_{net,SF} - T_{bld,SF}\,, \quad \Delta T_B = T_{net,RF} - T_{bld,RF}

Example: network 80/55 °C, building heating 70/50 °C yields ΔTA=10 K\Delta T_A = 10\,\text{K} and ΔTB=5 K\Delta T_B = 5\,\text{K}, hence ΔTlog,nom=(10−5)/ln⁡(10/5)≈7.2 K\Delta T_{log,nom} = (10-5)/\ln(10/5) \approx 7.2\,\text{K}. If both temperature differences are equal, then ΔTlog,nom=ΔTA=ΔTB\Delta T_{log,nom} = \Delta T_A = \Delta T_B.

Secondary side from the heating curve

The secondary side (building heating) is determined from the heating curve of the building:

  • Secondary supply setpoint TSF,secT_{SF,sec} = supply temperature of the heating curve at the current outdoor temperature (for a constant building demand: its constant heating setpoint). With domestic hot water and pre-defined time series it is raised: in DHW generation mode In scheduled time windows to the DHW supply temperature during the preparation windows, in With buffer storage mode with a separate DHW supply temperature weighted per hour by heating and charging energy (see Building demand in the detail editor)
  • Secondary spread ΔTsec\Delta T_{sec} = temperature difference of the heating curve (for a constant building demand: its constant spread)
  • Secondary return: TRF,sec=TSF,sec−ΔTsecT_{RF,sec} = T_{SF,sec} - \Delta T_{sec}
  • Secondary mass flux: m˙sec=Q˙target/(cp⋅ΔTsec)\dot m_{sec} = \dot Q_{target} / (c_p \cdot \Delta T_{sec}) with the target heat flux Q˙target\dot Q_{target} corrected by the storage term (see storage behavior)

With these boundary conditions the model solves the counter-flow heat exchanger analytically and delivers the actually transferred heat flux as well as the outlet temperatures of both sides. The primary-side mass flux is adjusted by the consumer’s control so that the transferred heat flux matches the building demand – as far as the transfer capacity and the network supply temperature allow.

Primary-side control

In the built-in plants, a controlled valve upstream of the station controls the secondary supply temperature. From the network supply temperature, the target heat flux and the secondary side, the model calculates the required primary mass flux and passes it to the valve as set point. The set point is recalculated at fixed intervals; its increase is limited so that the valve does not open abruptly. If the target heat flux cannot be reached even with ten times the nominal mass flux (network supply too cold), the valve opens fully – like a real temperature-controlled substation. Throttling would let the service pipe cool down further and lock the station in the undersupplied state.

Minimum modulation

The model supports a minimum modulation: if the required heat flux falls below the minimum power Q˙min=Q˙nom⋅fmod,min\dot Q_{min} = \dot Q_{nom} \cdot f_{mod,min}, the station transfers no heat. The minimum modulation is currently not adjustable in the user interface; the default value is 0, i.e. there is no minimum power.

Storage behavior

The model keeps an internal storage term EstE_{st}, which sums the difference between delivered and required heat over time:

Est(t)=∫(Q˙delivered−Q˙required) dtE_{st}(t) = \int \left( \dot Q_{delivered} - \dot Q_{required} \right) \, dt

A negative value is a delivery backlog, a positive one a delivery surplus. The storage level corrects the target heat flux with which the station is operated:

Q˙target=max⁡ ⁣(0,  Q˙Bld−k⋅Est)withk=0.001 1s\dot Q_{target} = \max\!\left(0,\; \dot Q_{Bld} - k \cdot E_{st}\right) \qquad \text{with} \quad k = 0.001\,\tfrac{1}{\text{s}}

A backlog thus increases the setpoint, a surplus lowers it – the accumulated energy difference is reduced again with a time constant of around 1000 s (≈ 17 minutes). The storage term is updated every 60 s and is not bounded: a long-lasting undersupply leads to a correspondingly long catch-up phase.

Physically, the storage term represents the thermal inertia of the building: short interruptions – for example briefly too-low supply temperatures – are not lost as energy, but are subsequently made up as soon as the conditions allow it. Over longer periods, the delivered energy sum thereby matches the demand profile. The current storage level is available as the output quantity StoredHeatingEnergy. If the backlog can no longer be reduced because of an insufficient network supply temperature, this shows up in the heat deficit outputs.

Parameters

ParameterUnitDefaultMeaning
Nominal heating powerkW10Design power of the station; for the sized variant automatically = connection power of the building
Design value of logarithmic temperature differenceK5Design value ΔTlog,nom\Delta T_{log,nom} for the UA value determination
Nominal volume flow ratem³/h2Reference volume flow for the pressure loss; sized variant: automatically from the connection power
Nominal pressure lossbar0.5Pressure loss at the nominal volume flow rate (quadratic scaling)

For the sized variant, only Nominal pressure loss and Design value of logarithmic temperature difference are entered. The fluid volume of the station is 10 L and cannot be edited in the user interface; smaller values from older projects are raised to 10 L when opening. The modulation level is fixed as well (0, see above).

Parameters of the substation with nominal heating power, logarithmic temperature difference, nominal pressure loss and nominal volume flow
Parameters of the substation: nominal heating power, design value of the logarithmic temperature difference, nominal pressure loss and nominal volume flow.

Use in the project

The substation is used in three ways:

WaySetup
Built-in plant SubstationControlled valve (control of the secondary supply temperature) and sized substation
Built-in plant Substation with bypassAs above, plus a thermostatic bypass parallel to valve and station
Simplified consumer with Model type: Detailed (secondary supply temperature control)Creates the same circuit internally; the Thermostatic bypass check box adds the bypass

The thermostatic bypass keeps the service pipe warm at low demand: the bypass valve opens as soon as the inlet temperature drops below 50 °C and is fully open at 46 °C. The valve and its control are described under Pressure losses & valves and Controller, the choice between the consumer models under Consumer model selection.

Behavior under undersupply

If the network supply temperature drops, the driving temperature gradient in the heat exchanger drops – the station can then no longer fully cover the building demand, even with an increased primary-side mass flux. The transferred heat flux decreases for physical reasons, instead of being extracted unchanged as with the simple heat exchanger.

Persistent deficits are reported as output quantities:

QuantityMeaning
RequiredBuildingHeatFluxHeat flux required by the building
HeatDeficitAbsoluteNon-deliverable heat flux [kW], as a time average, as soon as the delivery lies below 95 % of the requirement for longer than 30 minutes; only evaluated while the required heat flux exceeds 10 % of the nominal heating power (and the minimum power)
HeatDeficitRelativeDeficit relative to the nominal heating power
OutletTemperatureSecondary / -SetpointAchieved vs. required secondary supply temperature
InletTemperatureSecondarySecondary return temperature
StoredHeatingEnergyLevel of the internal storage term [kWh]: accumulated difference between delivered and required heat
TemperatureDifferencePrimary-side temperature difference (inlet minus outlet); 0 for an idle station (transferred power below 1 W)

What you need to watch out for: heating curve and network supply temperature

The model stands or falls with a correctly set heating curve per building – it defines the secondary setpoint against which the heat exchanger works:

  • The network supply temperature must lie above the secondary supply setpoint – and by at least the order of magnitude of the logarithmic design temperature difference. If, for example, the heating curve requires 70 °C at −12 °C outdoor temperature, but the network delivers only 72 °C, a station sized with ΔTlog,nom=5 K\Delta T_{log,nom} = 5\,\text{K} cannot cover the demand: a permanent deficit arises that lies not in the network but in the parameterization.
  • After the simulation, check the quantities HeatDeficitAbsolute and OutletTemperatureSecondary against the setpoint: systematic deviations already at mild outdoor temperatures indicate an unsuitable heating curve, deviations only on the coldest days indicate an actual capacity or temperature problem of the network.
  • A too optimistically (small) chosen logarithmic temperature difference feigns a too-capable heat exchanger – use datasheet values of the planned stations where available.

Stay up to date

New features, tutorials and updates delivered to your inbox.